By Jennifer Spenser
June 11, 2009
CLUSA Conference-Gardner-Webb University
- Schools buy into expensive programs and implement passing fads rather than invest in the foundational ideas that undergird methods of teaching.
- Methods alone do not make a school a Mason school; this produces shallow results
- No information should be given without an informing idea
A Look at Various Educational Models Used Throughout History
Classical Model
- Views learner as blank slate
- Knowledge derived from experience
- Three stages of learning: Grammar, Logic, Rhetoric
- Building from the bottom up
- Heavy Memorization of facts
- Teacher is the giver of knowledge
- Classic Literature, Language, Recitation, studies isolated from life
- Chronological study of history
- Mason did not subscribe to the Tabula-Rasa method
- Many poor children left behind
- Pre-Industrial revolution options for poor child: farming or tradesman
Industrial Revolution/Apprenticeship Model
- Factory owners recruited whole families, trained skilled laborers
- Began school run by the industry
- 1911 Frederick Taylor wrote Principles of Management; encouraged industry to monitor workers’ time not related to work
- Industry gets involved in Education; propaganda campaign to convince citizens that vocational training is good for America.
- Similar to German Model which placed education under the auspices of the Department of Commerce & Labor.
- Three types of learners: Cultural, Industrial, Factory
- Education is for social engineering
- Teachers are public servants; present ideas of controlling majority
- Principles of Industrial Education:
§ Education for training for trade/vocation
§ Children are raw material
§ Schools are like factory plants
§ Architecture of school building mimics factory, ie., classroom designed to look like shop floor
§ Middle school years explore possible vocations
§ Test for aptitude, “probable destiny”
§ Student placed into appropriate “tier”
§ Utilitarian methods: Standardized tests, textbooks, strict schedule
§ CM believed this type of education to be immoral
Humanitarian Progressivism
- Shifting Sand
- Against industry slavery of children, adults
- Persons above profit
- Wanted reform of industrial educational model
- Education is equalizer of opportunity
- John Dewey:
§ Science has potential to improve or debase society
§ Dominant vocation of humans is living
§ School environment: - Free play
- Hands on
- Democratic atmosphere
- Integrated curriculum
- Emulate real life
- Loop learning
- Balance of Liberal Arts & Vocational studies
- Free of authoritarianism
§ Education is intelligent art of shaping beliefs and desires of children
§ Education reform enough for social revolution
§ Education should have child-centered instruction - Learning centers
- Unit Study
§ Mason not child centered; she did not believe humans were at the center of the universe
§ Mason: Education is an Atmosphere
§ Even very young children are capable, insulted by twaddle
§ Students should dig for relationships between subjects not teachers
§ Contrived grouping of students silly to Mason
§ Outer character change, futile; only inner change produces real, lasting change
Mason’s Foundation
- After viewing “Triumph of St. Thomas Acquanis & the Allegory of the Sciences" by Andrea Da Firenze 1344-1377, Mason came to the impelling,underlying conclusion: All Knowledge is derived from God through the Holy Spirit.
- By studying Living Things, we learn that God is life
- Study of Math, God is form, order
- Study of Arts, God is beautiful
- Study of Languages, God communicates
- Study of History, we learn of the evolution of the relationship between God and man.
- Teacher spreads a feast of ideas before the learner
- Teacher allows student to ingest, digest what is proper for him
- Trinity of education, Knowledge of God, Knowledge of Man, Knowledge of the Universe
- Of God: Bible, character
- Of man: Humanities, Arts
- Universe: Science, math
- History is the pivot of a CM education
- Literature & Languages, Math & Science, Arts, Bible & Character extend from History studies
- All learning comes from Holy Spirit
- Mason approach connects learning: careful observations leads to relation to prior knowledge leads to assimilation of new knowledge leads to expression of knowledge leads to (?slide changed before I got it)
- Trivium, Grades, Behaviorism, Isolated Skills not needed in Mason method
No comments:
Post a Comment